Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam by Douglas N. Walton

By Douglas N. Walton

Entice pity has often been exploited with extraordinary good fortune as a misleading tactic of argumentation, a lot in order that it has routinely been handled as a fallacy. utilizing a case learn process, the writer examines examples of appeals to pity and compassion in genuine arguments for you to classify, study, and overview the categories of arguments utilized in those appeals. one of the instances studied are the arguable use of "poster children" within the Jerry Lewis Telethon for Muscular Dystrophy and the "baby incubators tale" deployed by means of a public kinfolk company to steer the choice to ship U.S. forces into Kuwait through the Gulf warfare. as well as the analyses of those and different case experiences, this e-book offers, for the 1st time, specified instructions and valuable standards with which to spot, learn, and overview circumstances of the advert misericordiam argument.

Show description

Read Online or Download Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam PDF

Best methodology books

New Racism: Revisiting Researcher Accountabilities

This publication combines the sociological exploration of individual in society with an exam of human realizing methods and their justification within the social textile. It connects this to discussions round race/ethnicity, gender, and sophistication concerns. The publication brings jointly those parts of inquiry and explores recommendations for boosting social learn on new racism.

Surveying the Social World: Principles and Practice in Survey Research (Understanding Social Research)

* What are the strengths and obstacles of social surveys? * How can the foundations of surveying be positioned into perform? * How are findings analysed and effects offered? The survey has develop into a everyday strategy for collecting details and critiques from participants, firms, and different teams.

Remembering the 1980 Turkish Military Coup d‘État: Memory, Violence, and Trauma

In her learn experiences, Elifcan Karacan indicates the relation among trauma, violence and reminiscence with a particular specialize in the occasions contemplating the 1980 army Coup d‘État in Turkey. in accordance with collective reminiscence theories and cultural trauma theories, the writer makes a speciality of the reconstruction of the prior in current occasions and reminiscence practices, comparable to commemorations, anniversaries, development of memory-places (museums).

Unifying Political Methodology: The Likelihood Theory of Statistical Inference

One of many hallmarks of the advance of political technological know-how as a self-discipline has been the construction of latest methodologies by way of students in the discipline--methodologies which are well-suited to the research of political information. Gary King has been a pace-setter within the improvement of those new methods to the research of political facts.

Additional resources for Appeal to Pity: Argumentum Ad Misericordiam

Example text

On the basis of this negative evidence, the best conjecture seems to be that the ad misericordiam was a late addition to the logic textbooks. Before the twentieth century, it had not been treated as a specific fallacy. Instead, this type of appeal had been included under the broader Aristotelian category of the ignoratio elenchi fallacy. However, there is evidence of some prior occurrence of the expression argumentum ad misericordiam, outside the field of logic. 2. Earliest Known Origins of Ad Misericordiam Some clues to early uses of the term ad misericordiam are given in the Oxford English Dictionary entry (Simpson and Weiner 1989, p.

This was when I had to go home to see my brother who was just in a car crash. Otherwise I would have been prepared for your test and would have taken it. I know you have a "no make-up" policy. But I really couldn't help what has happened to my parents and < previous page page_21 If you like this book, buy it! next page > < previous page page_22 next page > Page 22 brother. It is only fair to permit me to make up a missed quiz. One ought to do what is fair. So, you ought to allow me to take the test.

They don't appear to think the differences are significant, or worth commenting on. In fairness, this < previous page page_33 If you like this book, buy it! next page > < previous page page_34 next page > Page 34 may be due to the short space allotted to the argumentum ad misericordiam in the textbooks. There is a general presumption that the argumentum ad misericordiam is fallacious, especially in the earlier textbooks. But this seems to be changing, in at least a fair number of the textbooks, where it now often tends to be acknowledged explicitly that this type of argument can be nonfallacious in some cases.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.71 of 5 – based on 49 votes